Royal College welcomes decision on Bawa-Garba case

Dr Jackie Taylor, the President-Elect of the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Glasgow has commented on behalf of the College following the ruling by the Court of Appeal on Monday 13th August to overturn the High Court’s decision to strike Dr Bawa-Garba off the medical register earlier this year.

Royal College welcomes decision on Bawa-Garba case

Commenting following the ruling by the Court of Appeal on Monday 13th August to overturn the High Court’s decision to strike Dr Bawa-Garba off the medical register earlier this year, Dr Jackie Taylor, the President-Elect of the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Glasgow said:

“We welcome this decision by the Court of Appeal.

“We particularly welcome the clarity that it has brought to the role of the Medical Practitioners’ Tribunal Service and the courts when dealing with medical issues.

“Today’s judgement also made clear that the original decision to suspend Dr Bawa-Garba from medical practice fully took into account the range of external factors and failures which led to the tragic death of Jack Adcock. Blaming a single individual for systematic failures is not appropriate and certainly not in the public interest.

“The current GMC review of gross negligence manslaughter and culpable homicide has also been brought into focus by this decision. We will continue to engage with this review and other bodies on behalf of our membership to ensure that they bring forward a range of constructive proposals.

“The whole profession now needs to reflect on this case in order to create a no-blame culture within the NHS, which would be in the best interests of patients, clinicians and the NHS as a whole.”


Back to all articles


We provide a daily update on the day’s top health news by WhatsApp. To subscribe, please add our number (+447458012663) to your contacts as “College Voice” and then send "NEWS" as a WhatsApp message to +447458012663 for a daily update for the news that matters to you.

Who we are

We are a worldwide community of inspiring health professionals working together to advance our profession and improve patient care.

Read more

What we do

Over the past year we’ve made great advances in professionalising our approach to engaging more effectively with government and the wider health sector.

Read more

What we stand for

Together we are demanding action to address workforce shortages and implement solutions to help reduce staff burnout.

Read more